Page 2 of 3

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: February 12th, 2019, 10:19 pm
by bullit27
Arrived today and cannot stop reading , fantastic book....great title and ditto introduction by the writers, thank you both very much.... have to admit though that I am one of the nit pickers thet did not like " a day in the life of the dummies" cause I still don't like Jim's singing voice whether he can sing or not , so Poland is my favourite number on that one, like it more than LMLITY.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: February 12th, 2019, 10:29 pm
by bullit27
Ps hope the band themselves will also be very proud that 2 of their fans put so much research in the recording history of the band; must be a " oh yeah" experience for them reading about everything they did in the past......

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: February 12th, 2019, 10:33 pm
by bullit27
A wonderful tribute to a great band *like

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: February 13th, 2019, 1:31 am
by admin
The next issue of Shindig (#89) will have this in it.

Image

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: February 13th, 2019, 11:22 am
by mds
*like The reviewer is spot on.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: February 14th, 2019, 6:00 pm
by banginman

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: February 15th, 2019, 5:02 am
by steveclassic
WOW! Great review, congratulations Gents! Looking forward to sourcing my copy once we get Amazon sorted out. *boozy

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: February 17th, 2019, 11:47 pm
by admin
Chris Charlesworth has posted a review at http://justbackdated.blogspot.co.uk/search/label/Slade

THE NOIZE: The Slade Discography by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby

The affection in which Slade are held by a small but dedicated group of fans has taken tangible form in a new book by two of that number, Ian Edmundson and Chris Selby, whose The Noize: The Slade Discography, a privately produced and funded initiative, is now available on Amazon via print on demand, priced at a little over £20. By combining their Slade knowledge, record collections and cuttings files, the two authors have created an unauthorised but discrete history of the band that is signposted chronologically by their singles and albums, all the way from the first ‘N Betweens single in 1965 through the glory and doldrums years to the most recent solo recording, which just happens to be Jim Lea’s 2018 six-track EP Lost In Space.

Well, it’s a good job somebody out there cares. I belong to a school of thought that believes Slade have to a certain extent been unjustly written out of rock history through efforts by music industry bigwigs to disregard their achievements. Part of this is due to snobbery. Provincial to a tee, Slade never played the industry game, never behaved deferentially towards persons of influence, never minded their p’s and q’s in polite company. The situation is not helped by an unimaginative re-issue programme that is unlikely to tempt fans to part with their money and what seems to be an ongoing and rather unseemly disagreement between former members with regard to who contributed the lion’s share of creative effort into their many hits. This latter issue has been bubbling under for a while now, surfacing only occasionally when one of the antagonists feels inclined to speak out, but it never makes headlines because it’s not really news.

Furthermore, you don’t need a degree in music business lore to deduce that while the group’s songwriters, Noddy Holder and Jim Lea, have emerged from the Slade saga as men of substance, the two junior partners, Dave Hill and Don Powell, have not been so lucky – the fate of non-writing band members everywhere – otherwise they wouldn’t be obliged to tread the boards as Slade II. This endeavour, tolerated but hardly encouraged by Holder and Lea, has now been put on hold following the snapped tendons in both legs that Powell suffered while changing trains on his way to a gig in Wakefield in the north of England late last year, a cruel turn of fortune for one of the nicest men I know.

All of which must distress fans like Ian Edmundson and Chris Selby whose book is a true labour of love that reflects a lifelong devotion to the cause, though they demur at addressing any of the issues that I refer to above. As thorough as it is enjoyable in a nostalgic sense, the 206-page large format book tells Slade’s story from an authoritative perspective that relies on published accounts interspersed with quotes from the band to reinforce this. The record releases are illustrated with hundreds of sleeves, labels and images used to promote them, almost all of which are in colour. More than anything else, turning the pages makes it abundantly clear that Slade were far more prolific than is suggested by their glorious chart run in the first half of the seventies.

Particularly interesting for me is the period between that July 1965 ‘N Betweens single and when Chas Chandler ‘discovered’ them around the middle of 1969. Aside from some early efforts by pre-Slade groups, a number of singles were released, as was the rather unfocussed LP Beginnings by Ambrose Slade, every track of which is analysed here. When Ambrose was dropped they were billed as The Slade on Chandler’s first production, ‘Wild Winds Are Blowing’, which coincided with their ill-advised skinhead phase. In 1996, Slade fan John Haxby collected 25 even earlier recordings – not unlike the early tracks on The Beatles’ Anthology 1 – by The Vendors (featuring Hill and Powell), Steve Brett & The Mavericks (featuring Holder) and two editions of The ‘N Betweens (the first featuring Slade with John Howells on vocals, the second just the crucial four) on a fascinating CD entitled The Genesis of Slade, and all of these little-known tracks are discussed in The Noize.

Even with Chandler at the helm it took a while before Slade’s breakthrough arrived. It finally happened in 1971 with ‘Get Down And Get With It’ (aka ‘Get Down With It’, as labels here indicate) and, not long after, ‘Coz I Luv You’, the first Holder/Lea composition, the first to top the charts and the first to utilise the phonetic spellings that caused such anguish in teachers’ common rooms. By this time I’d become aware of the group and was writing enthusiastic reviews in Melody Maker, largely inspired by the excitement they generated at live shows. “They’re a breath of fresh eayer,” Chandler would yell at me over the din in his slightly threatening Geordie accent. Indeed, here was a group that had honed their craft over hundreds of nights in clubs and pubs up and down the land, an apprenticeship that would ensure their fortunes for as long as they plied their trade. Appropriately, then, it was their 1972 live LP, Slade Alive, that sealed matters, spending 58 weeks on the charts, far and away the longest of any Slade album.

Recorded over three nights – October 19, 20 & 21, 1971 – at Command Studios in Piccadilly at a cost of only £600, I was present on the 20th, a Wednesday. Earlier that day, in the late afternoon, Slade had recorded an appearance on Tops Of The Pops, performing ‘Coz I Luv You’. Euphoric at having reached number one for the first time, they arrived at the studio straight from the BBC Centre in Shepherds Bush in a state of high excitement, and it would be an understatement to say that, with Noddy leading the charge, the four boys from the Black Country were at Olympic fitness that night. Five years of hard slog had finally paid dividends and as I watched the “Full poke, Charlie!” show from among an audience of 300 I knew I’d picked a winner.

Fittingly, over four pages are devoted to this landmark release and thereafter The Noize details the upcoming glory years with all the LPs, picture sleeves and labels you would expect. Slade had 12 top five singles between 1971 and 1974, including six number ones, and three number one albums, making them the country’s most consistent hit makers in an era when the competition – T. Rex, Bowie, Rod and Elton among them – was at its most intense.

Slade’s progress is summarised in text that prefaces each year’s releases, and I was delighted to note that in their review of 1973 – a key Slade year – Edmundson and Selby draw attention to the US group Kiss’ adoption of Slade’s style: “Kiss saw the band in concert in New York and consciously adopted the whole Slade attitude,” they write, “some of the dress sense and to an extent the general sound of Slade on their own recordings.” The authors add that Kiss’ hit ‘Rock And Roll All Nite’ – note the misspelling – even included the lyric, “You drive us wild, we’ll drive you crazy.” Kiss, of course, have been inducted into America’s Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Why not Slade?

In many respects 1973 was an apogee for the group. Though the year ended with their biggest hit, ‘Merry Christmas Everybody’, it was their last number one, and thereafter, gradually, things would calm down for them. Nevertheless, an aspect of Slade’s career that is truly reflected in The Noize is how Slade never gave up trying when the chips were down. They battled fashion, a punk backlash and indifference, enjoyed a brief renaissance in the early eighties and carried on releasing records throughout the decade, and all these later releases on a myriad of Chandler-backed labels are carefully listed and annotated.

Slade last played together before a paying audience in 1984, but there was one final, brief appearance, at the 25th Anniversary Slade Fan Convention at Walsall Town Hall in 1991. What happened that day is described for the first time in some detail in The Noize, and I won’t spoil things by revealing it here, but Slade as a live band were effectively dormant from that day onwards. As Jim Lea puts it, “I drifted into drifting.”

It seems fitting here to mention for those unaware of it that between 1971 and 1975 I probably wrote more about Slade than any other music writer, and more enthusiastically too. Like the authors of The Noize, my fondness for Slade also never waned and in 1983 I was commissioned by Omnibus Press to write a book about them. I approached Chas Chandler who, in exchange for copyright control, agreed to co-operate, and as a result the book, titled Slade: Feel The Noize!, carried the word ‘OFFICIAL’ on its front cover. I interviewed the band, who’d become friends of mine over the years, and various people associated with their career, including chief roadie Graham Swinnerton, who sadly died in 2015, their PR Keith Altham and even Louise Lea, Jim’s wife, who related the hair-raising saga of a New York bank robbery that occurred while she, Leandra Holder and Jan Hill were queueing for a teller.

Although the book was ‘authorised’, the members of the group and others were remarkably candid about their lives and the ups and downs of Slade’s career. No one, not Chandler or the band, requested text approval. Perhaps in hindsight some of them now feel they were a bit too candid, and this might explain why the book has been allowed to go out of print, effectively suppressed by the heirs to Chandler’s business interests, and why I haven’t been asked to update it. Nevertheless, I’m gratified to learn that most fans still consider it the ‘Slade Bible’. (Used copies occasionally appear on Amazon for anything between £50 and £100.)

When I lent my support to the Genesis of Slade CD project, giving my go-ahead to use text from my book in its sleeve notes, I felt the wrath of those who control Slade’s business affairs come down upon me. Although the compilers had cleared the necessary copyrights, the management considered I was out of line and that the CD was ‘unauthorised’. I’m not quite persona no grata – and I’m still on very good terms with two members of the band – but I didn’t help my cause by publishing Don Powell’s book, which wasn’t approved by the same corporate interests, and commissioning for Omnibus Press a further ‘unauthorised’ Slade biography which has yet to be published.

I’m confident it will appear before long, even though its original author has been replaced, and in the meantime Ian Edmundson and Chris Selby’s book The Noize will act as a fitting tribute – and a nice companion to my own book – to a band I’ll always remember with enormous affection – that “breath of fresh eayer” that my old pal Chas drummed into me all those years ago.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: February 18th, 2019, 11:56 am
by mds
Interesting review by Mr. Charlesworth,

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 1st, 2019, 4:01 am
by steveclassic
mds wrote: February 18th, 2019, 11:56 am Interesting review by Mr. Charlesworth,
Hi Ian, I can't locate the post about the book not being available in Australia, so am posting here. (I'll look forward to the CC review at another time).

I did reply to your PM with my postal details, but the message is still in my "outbox" so I'm concerned you haven't yet received it. Would you please be able to confirm?

If you haven't received it, please PM your email address and I'll email you postal/email details.

Cheers, Steve

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 1st, 2019, 6:23 am
by steveclassic
mds wrote: February 18th, 2019, 11:56 am Interesting review by Mr. Charlesworth,
That's an understatement by half!

Aside from the very complimentary overview of The Noize (and its authors Ian and Chris), Mr Charlesworth makes some fascinating observations about the current relationships between the four main players.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 1st, 2019, 4:22 pm
by admin
One thing I avoided when writing, was putting words in the band's mouths. That way leads only to problems. There is nothing in the book that those band members who have the book could object to. I was more than careful about that!!!

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 1st, 2019, 10:10 pm
by steveclassic
"Just the facts Ma'am, just the facts"

Very wise policy

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 8th, 2019, 5:01 am
by steveclassic
admin wrote: February 17th, 2019, 11:47 pm Chris Charlesworth has posted a review at http://justbackdated.blogspot.co.uk/search/label/Slade

THE NOIZE: The Slade Discography by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby

...I belong to a school of thought that believes Slade have to a certain extent been unjustly written out of rock history through efforts by music industry bigwigs to disregard their achievements...

... The situation is not helped by ... what seems to be an ongoing and rather unseemly disagreement between former members with regard to who contributed the lion’s share of creative effort into their many hits. This latter issue has been bubbling under for a while now, surfacing only occasionally when one of the antagonists feels inclined to speak out...
Am I alone in believing that this is a not-so-thinly-veiled observation that it is Jim Lea that Chris Charlesworth is referring to here?

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 8th, 2019, 10:01 am
by mds
steveclassic wrote: March 8th, 2019, 5:01 am
admin wrote: February 17th, 2019, 11:47 pm Chris Charlesworth has posted a review at http://justbackdated.blogspot.co.uk/search/label/Slade

THE NOIZE: The Slade Discography by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby

...I belong to a school of thought that believes Slade have to a certain extent been unjustly written out of rock history through efforts by music industry bigwigs to disregard their achievements...

... The situation is not helped by ... what seems to be an ongoing and rather unseemly disagreement between former members with regard to who contributed the lion’s share of creative effort into their many hits. This latter issue has been bubbling under for a while now, surfacing only occasionally when one of the antagonists feels inclined to speak out...

Am I alone in believing that this is a not-so-thinly-veiled observation that it is Jim Lea that Chris Charlesworth is referring to here?
I had the same impression Steve. JWL's recent (past ten years or so) interviews and comments would lead one to believe that he wrote most of, if not all, the post Play It Loud era music and a decent amount of the lyrics as well.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 9th, 2019, 2:19 am
by steveclassic
mds wrote: March 8th, 2019, 10:01 am I had the same impression Steve. JWL's recent (past ten years or so) interviews and comments would lead one to believe that he wrote most of, if not all, the post Play It Loud era music and a decent amount of the lyrics as well.
Cheers Matt, it's almost as if Jim, after years of remaining low key (in the extreme), has had some kind of epiphany after years of hearing Noddy all over radio and TV in the UK regaling people with the Slade war stories, and has decided to subtly intervene.

My facts on this may be a bit off, but I remember only a few years back reading a report somewhere (perhaps here) that in the lead up to Xmas, Jim had sent the BBC a letter asking/insisting that any reference to MXE and Noddy Holder should also include an acknowledgement that Jim Lea was also involved in writing that song. Or words to that effect.

It does seem a shame though, that if there is any truth behind this theory, that Nod and Jim could not convene a simple meeting and agree that when Nod is out and about spruiking his stories on the Slade years, that he acknowledge Jim's input into the songs to a greater degree than he has in the past.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 9th, 2019, 12:51 pm
by mds
steveclassic wrote: March 9th, 2019, 2:19 am It does seem a shame though, that if there is any truth behind this theory, that Nod and Jim could not convene a simple meeting and agree that when Nod is out and about spruiking his stories on the Slade years, that he acknowledge Jim's input into the songs to a greater degree than he has in the past.
Fully agree. I don't think it is intentional but Nod, especially with his MXE regaling, tends to shade things in his direction.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 11th, 2019, 8:40 pm
by davidj64
If Noddy's doing the interviews then it's him the questions are going to be about and naturally he'll self-promote.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 16th, 2019, 4:34 am
by steveclassic
This was published by Buzzfeed News in December 2016:

It might be the best-known Christmas pop song, but one of its co-authors is not so full of festive cheer when it comes to getting credit for writing it.
Jim Lea, the former bass player with Slade, who with singer Noddy Holder wrote "Merry Xmas Everybody", has complained to the BBC for claiming that Holder was the song's sole author.
The song, which topped charts on its released in 1973 and has sold more than a million copies, is still a mainstay of radio playlists in the weeks before Christmas – and the BBC has warned staff not to get it wrong when talking about the song on air.
An internal email, which has been seen by BuzzFeed News, was sent to staff this week.
It said that Lea complained during Christmas last year about two TV programmes, Top of the Pops 2and Back in Time For Christmas, that Lea claimed had implied Holder was the sole author.
"The BBC agreed to correct these statements without any admission of legal liability," the email said.
"Jim Lea’s lawyers have recently written to ask that any proposed BBC output does not repeat the suggestion that 'Merry Xmas Everybody' is the sole work of Noddy Holder. We wish to ensure that wider programme teams who are likely to refer to the authorship of the song are aware of Jim Lea’s position that he co-wrote it."
Thought to be one of the most widely heard songs in the English language, "Merry Xmas Everybody" came to Lea while he was in the shower, he has said.
"Chas [Chandler, the band's manager] said ‘The thing is Jim, it would be nice to be in the charts at Christmas’. And he said ‘You know what, it would be even nicer to be number one at Christmas’.
“So I went into the shower and got the lovely warm water on me. I just said to myself – and I was almost talking to my own brain – ‘Come on, do it now’. And lo and behold I pieced the whole thing together. I was really pleased with it. I got that melody – the chorus – and I thought what’s it about?
“Then I remember what Chas had said. And I literally started singing ‘So here it is, Merry Xmas, Everybody’s having fun’.”

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 19th, 2019, 11:59 pm
by steveclassic
Received my copy of The Noize this morning. Arrived in mint condition. After a cursory glance I have to say I am impressed!

Review to follow.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 20th, 2019, 12:14 pm
by admin
*kor

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 21st, 2019, 12:27 pm
by mds
steveclassic wrote: March 16th, 2019, 4:34 am This was published by Buzzfeed News in December 2016:
Thought to be one of the most widely heard songs in the English language, "Merry Xmas Everybody" came to Lea while he was in the shower, he has said.
"Chas [Chandler, the band's manager] said ‘The thing is Jim, it would be nice to be in the charts at Christmas’. And he said ‘You know what, it would be even nicer to be number one at Christmas’.
“So I went into the shower and got the lovely warm water on me. I just said to myself – and I was almost talking to my own brain – ‘Come on, do it now’. And lo and behold I pieced the whole thing together. I was really pleased with it. I got that melody – the chorus – and I thought what’s it about?
“Then I remember what Chas had said. And I literally started singing ‘So here it is, Merry Xmas, Everybody’s having fun’.”
This is where it gets dicey. In the past JWL said that he took the chorus of Nod's Buy Me A Rocking Chair and built the song from there. It is likely accurate that Jim came up with the chorus lyric based on Chas's Christmas chart #1 suggestion but it is also likely that Nod came up with the verses per his retelling over the years. What is clear after all these years is that Jim created the majority, if not all, of Slade's music from 1972-1991 and probably had a hand in the lyric writing, primarily chorus and song title, as well. He isn't seeking all of the songwriting credit; just acknowledgment of his contribution.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 22nd, 2019, 2:22 am
by steveclassic
mds wrote: March 21st, 2019, 12:27 pm ... This is where it gets dicey... What is clear after all these years is that Jim created the majority, if not all, of Slade's music from 1972-1991 and probably had a hand in the lyric writing, primarily chorus and song title, as well. He isn't seeking all of the songwriting credit; just acknowledgement of his contribution.
Very well said Matt!

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 22nd, 2019, 2:39 am
by steveclassic
The Noize

My copy arrived in excellent condition. An initial ten minute skim through the entire book confirmed that this particular tome could have almost been compiled and written especially for me!

Although I am currently only up to page 43 and the release of Take Me Bak ‘Ome in May 1972, I’m very happy to say that this is indeed an excellent publication. A few very minor typos aside (mainly an occasional ‘an’ instead of ‘and’ and vice versa), given the high standard of the writing, attention to detail, the generous number of pics and images, and the overall layout and packaging, one could easily believe this release is from an international publishing house, instead of two passionate – albeit knowledgeable and articulate – Slade fans.

The story of Nod, Don, Jim and Dave’s individual and collective recordings up to and including Slade Alive! (which was my introduction to the band) has in itself been worth the price of this book. I am truly excited at the prospect of leisurely soaking up the stories of Slade’s heyday years of recording, which is the era of their work that is of the most vital importance to this fan.

And such is the high quality of the narrative, I am equally as enthusiastic to learn more about the recordings from the late 70s through to the final records. Hell, I’m even excited about learning more about the ‘Jim Lea Band’ era!

The Noize truly is a ‘must have’ for any Slade fan who has more than just a passing interest in their music. My copy - along with my signed copy of Lise and Don’s Look Wot I Dun - is now a vital part of my collection of all things Slade.

9.5/10

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 24th, 2019, 6:09 am
by steveclassic
Having now read my way through to the end of 1976, there are several observations in the book that I can only describe as fscinating!

1) The John Peel retrospective review of PIL. I was so blown away with what he had written that I found half an hour of peace this afternoon that I utilised to rudely disturb that peace with a pretty loud run through of PIL.

2) I've been consistenly astonished with many of the US reviews (including those from seriously influential publications such as Cashox and Billboard), that wholeheartedly endorse the vast majority of Slade's 72-75 era singles and albums and publicly claiming that the band's stateside breakthrough was surely imminent! . I have always been of the belief that the US music press offered little support to Slade during those years where they huge everywhere else. So that's been a real turn up for the books for me.

3) I've never really given this much thought, but now that it's been drawn to my attention, I simply CANNOT BELIEVE that Slade's US record label at the time did not put out (and heavily promote) a single of release of Far Far Away in early 1975. Managed carefully, that could have truly been the making of Slade in America. A truly, negligent decision IMO!

4) We woz robbed in Australia : no insert sheet with lyrics with the Oz release of Nobody's Fools

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 30th, 2019, 12:09 am
by admin
Put back in here from polls for a week or two.

Can people please review it on AMAZON? Thanks.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: March 30th, 2019, 8:53 am
by steveclassic
admin wrote: March 30th, 2019, 12:09 am Put back in here from polls for a week or two.

Can people please review it on AMAZON? Thanks.
Will do!

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: April 12th, 2019, 11:20 am
by admin
Watch out for a review in Record Collector shortly.
Goldmine in the USA are also reviewing it at present.

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: April 13th, 2019, 7:04 pm
by kelvinht
admin wrote: April 12th, 2019, 11:20 am Watch out for a review in Record Collector shortly.
Goldmine in the USA are also reviewing it at present.
*kor

Re: THE NOIZE by Ian Edmundson & Chris Selby. YOUR REVIEWS.

Posted: August 31st, 2019, 2:13 am
by admin
I've dropped this back into the main forum, in case some of you haven't seen it to comment.

Anyone, who has got the book - your comments are really welcomed.